Budget Leases

Apartments for Rent in Middletown, NY

Rents in Middletown, NY start at $1,100/mo on Budget Leases, and the average across the 7 listings we track runs $1,904/mo. That puts Middletown roughly 14% below the NY state average of $2,206/mo, so it's one of the more affordable markets in the state. By size, expect one-bedrooms around $2,055/mo and two-bedrooms around $1,950/mo. Listings are ranked cheapest-first and updated regularly.

Updated Jun 9, 2026

Cheapest
$1,100
lowest listed rent
Average rent
$1,90414% below NY
across all sizes
Average by sizevs NY typical
Studio$1,10055% below NY
1 bed$2,055~ NY avg
2 bed$1,9506% below NY

7 rentals in Middletown, NY

Every size & style, ranked by price

Renting in Middletown, NY: common questions

How much is rent in Middletown, NY?
The average asking rent across the 7 listings we track in Middletown, NY is $1,904/mo, with the cheapest starting at $1,100/mo. Prices change often, so confirm current rates on each listing.
What is the cheapest apartment for rent in Middletown?
North St Apartments is the lowest-priced rental we're tracking in Middletown, NY at $1,100/mo. We rank every listing cheapest-first so the best-value options are always at the top.
What is the average rent by bedroom in Middletown?
Based on the listings we track in Middletown, NY: studios around $1,100/mo, one-bedrooms around $2,055/mo, two-bedrooms around $1,950/mo. These are averages and shift with availability.
Is Middletown expensive to rent in?
Relatively no. Middletown's average rent of $1,904/mo is about 14% below the NY state average of $2,206/mo, making it one of the more affordable markets in the state.

Looking beyond Middletown?

Search any city, neighborhood, or building, or jump to a nearby market.

Nearby cities
Goshen, NYMount Arlington, PANewburgh, NYWappingers Falls, NYSuffern, NYPeekskill, NYFishkill, NYSpring Valley, NY
Browse all rentals across the US